How to Choose the Right Superfeet Insole

Buyer's Guide | Fleet Feet

Updated on

What Superfeet Can Do For You

Similar to orthotics, Superfeet Insoles add comfortable arch and heel support to your footwear.

Superfeet insoles can be a useful tool for:

  1. Controlling over-pronation or supination.
  2. Relief from plantar fasciitis, Achilles tendonitis, foot, ankle, heel, knee, hip and lower back pain.
  3. Reducing the risk of injury from running, walking and other activities.

5 Problems Insoles Can Solve

What’s the Difference Between Superfeet Insole Colors?

Superfeet insoles come in a variety of arch shapes, profiles, cushion levels, and support. Below we define what each specification means for your foot and comfort.

  • Support (responsive or dynamic?): This refers to the structure of the insole beneath your heel and arch. Responsive support means your Superfeet will have a firm feel in the arch and heel. Dynamic support means the insole will flex with your foot and arch as you move through your gait.
  • Arch Shape: The shape and height of the insole beneath your arches and heel. If your feet have high arches, you may prefer Superfeet with a medium-high arch shape. If you have flat feet or low arches, look for something with a low-medium arch shape. If you are not sure what type of arch you have, visit one of our Fleet Feet locations for a fitidÂŽ 3D scan.
  • Insole Thickness: The amount of space the insole will take up in your shoe. Models with a max thickness use more space and work best in footwear with a removable liner. Low to medium thickness Superfeet take up less space and work well in moderate-tight fitting footwear, even some without removable liners.
  • Cushion: Ranging from soft to firm, Superfeet offers a variety of cushion levels from memory foam to full-length AeroSpring Rebound foam with gel in the heel.

How to Pick the Best Superfeet for You?

Everyone’s feet are different. So when deciding what Superfeet you need, first know that there is no single best insole for everyone.

So how do you choose between Superfeet All-Purpose Support, Run Dynamic Cushion and Run Support among many others?

Your arch height, foot shape, instep and lifestyle can be helpful indicators, but ultimately, your comfort and intended use will be the best way to choose which Superfeet you need.

To help you narrow it down, we’ve put together a list of the best Superfeet Insoles for running, walking, work, casual wear, sports, pain relief, plantar fasciitis, flat feet and all-around use while pointing out some key differences between them so you can find the perfect fit and support.

Best For Running & Walking

Best for All-Purpose Use

Best for Pain Relief & Sensitive Feet

Best for Casual Wear, Dress Shoes, High Heels & Work

Best for Personalized Support

This is part of our Best Running Accessories Guide 2024. For more expert advice on the best gear for runners, check out our top lists of the best running shoes, best running clothes and best massage tools.

Still unsure? The best way to make sure you are using the correct shape and color insole is to go to your local Fleet Feet to get fit for Superfeet insoles using our 3D foot-scanning technology.

Best for Running & Walking

A person holding a Superfeet insole, perfect gifts for runners

Superfeet Run Dynamic Cushion Low Arch & Dynamic Cushion High Arch

Shop Now

Superfeet Run Dynamic Cushion Low Arch & Run Dynamic Cushion High Arch Insoles are made to get out of the way so you can focus on your run. For flexible support that helps your feet move the way they were designed to and fight fatigue, choose between the low arch or high arch support. Both use Adaptive Comfort Technology that flexes with the foot for a more efficient heel-to-toe turnover while running or walking.

Specs

Superfeet Run Dynamic Cushion Low Arch & Dynamic Cushion High Arch

What it’s best for

Running, walking

Support (responsive or dynamic?)

Dynamic

Arch shape

Low-medium (Dynamic Cushion Low Arch), medium-high (Dynamic Cushion High Arch)

Insole thickness

Max

Cushion

Soft, extra heel and forefoot zone cushioning


Superfeet Run Support High Arch

Shop Now

Superfeet Run Support High Arch Insoles use a responsive EVOLyteÂŽ carbon fiber cap to give you medium to high arch support and two layers of AeroSpring Rebound foam for ultimate comfort and performance. A pod of gel made for high-impact heel strikes disperses impact for a smooth and easy ride.

Specs

Superfeet Run Support High Arch

What it’s best for

Running, walking

Support (responsive or dynamic?)

Responsive

Arch shape

Medium-high

Insole thickness

Max

Cushion

Soft, full-length AeroSpring Rebound foam with gel in the heel

Superfeet Run Support Medium Arch

Shop Now

For Run Support performance in a thinner package, Superfeet Run Support Medium Arch Insoles gives you a slightly lower arch shape and comes with the same foam cushioning and high-impact heel gel and the Run Support High Arch model. Plus, it fits into moderate to tight-fitting running and walking shoes, even some without removable liners.

Specs

Superfeet Run Support Medium Arch

What it’s best for

Running, walking

Support (responsive or dynamic?)

Responsive

Arch shape

Medium

Insole thickness

Medium

Cushion

Soft, full-length AeroSpring Rebound foam with gel in the heel

Superfeet Run Women's Support

Shop Now

Made for running and walking, Superfeet Run Women’s Support can help reduce foot fatigue and gain efficiency. Designed using women-specific dimensions, these insoles fit narrower in the heel while the medium to high arch shape supports tired, achy feet.

Specs

Superfeet Run Women’s Support

What it’s best for

Running, walking

Support (responsive or dynamic?)

Responsive

Arch shape

Medium-high, women’s specific shape

Insole thickness

Max

Cushion

Soft, full-length AeroSpring Rebound foam with gel in the heel

Best for All-Purpose Use

Superfeet All-Purpose Support High Arch (Green)

Shop Now

The original Superfeet All-Purpose Support High Arch (Green) is legendary for its comfort and support. It has a firm and high arch shape and deep heel cup—making them best for those with medium-high arches. Have wide feet? For the same support in a wider package, try Superfeet All-Purpose Wide Fit Support (WideGreen).

Specs

Superfeet All-Purpose Support High Arch (Green)

What it’s best for

All-purpose use

Support (responsive or dynamic?)

Responsive

Arch shape

High

Insole thickness

Max

Cushion

Firm

Superfeet All-Purpose Women's High Impact Support (Berry)

Shop Now

While anyone can wear this insole, Superfeet All-Purpose Women's High Impact Support (Berry) was designed to fit the proportions of the female foot. This gives the insole a narrower fit and women’s-specific, medium-high arch shape. Superfeet also added high-impact foam to the forefoot for greater shock absorption when you’re walking, running or playing on hard, unforgiving surfaces.

Specs

Superfeet All-Purpose Women's High Impact Support (Berry)

What it’s best for

All-purpose use, High-impact use

Support (responsive or dynamic?)

Responsive

Arch shape

Medium, women’s specific shape

Insole thickness

Max

Cushion

Firm in heel with extra forefoot cushioning

Superfeet Run Support Low Arch

Shop Now

Using the strength of carbon fiber paired with ultralight foam, Superfeet Run Support Low Arch insoles are one of the most innovative, high-performance Superfeet ever. Their low yet distinct biomechanical arch shape and slim design help improve the fit and feel of tight-fitting athletic footwear like running shoes, bike shoes, cleats and track spikes.

Specs

Superfeet Run Support Low Arch

What it’s best for

All-purpose use, High-impact use

Support (responsive or dynamic?)

Responsive

Arch shape

Low

Insole thickness

Low

Cushion

Firm

Best for Pain Relief & Sensitive Feet

Superfeet Run Pain Relief

Shop Now

When you’re running with foot, arch or heel pain from injuries like plantar fasciitis or Achilles tendonitis, Superfeet Run Pain Relief uses therapeutic foam and a gentle, medium to high arch shape to reduce foot pain and hot spots so you can keep training. For extra structure and support, they also come with independent heel stabilizers to hold the insole’s pain-relieving shape closer to your foot.

Specs

Superfeet Run Pain Relief

What it’s best for

Running, walking, pain relief

Support (responsive or dynamic?)

Responsive

Arch shape

All shapes

Insole thickness

Max

Cushion

Soft, therapeutic foam

Best for Dress Shoes, High Heels & Work

Superfeet Casual Women’s Easyfit®, Casual Easyfit® High Heel & Casual Men’s Easyfit®

Shop Now

Best for tight-fitting dress shoes, high heels and flats, Superfeet Casual EasyfitÂŽ insoles require no trimming—they simply drop into the back of your shoe. It’s a half-length insole that still gives you the same amazing shape and support Superfeet is known for. Slip them into any dress or work shoes, high heels, or flats for all-day comfort.

Specs

Superfeet Casual Easyfit

What it’s best for

Work, everyday use

Support (responsive or dynamic?)

Responsive

Arch shape

All arch heights

Insole thickness

Low

Cushion

Firm, microsuede top layer

Best For Personalized Support

Superfeet ME3D & ME3D Max

For personalized support built specifically for the way you move, book an appointment at your local Fleet Feet* to get fit for Superfeet ME3D or ME3D Max. ME3D insoles are 3D printed running and walking shoe insoles that give you low-profile, lightweight support based on your unique foot shape, gait and pressure zones. The result is a comfortable insole built just for you to support your body and foot’s preferred motion path. Plus, the ME3D Max Insole adds premium dual-layer cushioning.

*ME3D Insoles are available at select Fleet Feet stores. Find a Fleet Feet location near you.

Specs

Superfeet ME3D & ME3D Max

What it’s best for

Personalized fit, all-purpose use, running, walking

Support (responsive or dynamic?)

Variable

Arch shape

Personalized

Insole thickness

Low (ME3D), Max (ME3D Max)

Cushion

Soft, responsive

More About Superfeet Insoles


How We Tested the Best Superfeet Insoles

With more than 250 stores in communities across the country, Fleet Feet is the largest running store in the U.S. with more than four decades of experience outfitting runners with the best running insoles, shoes, apparel and gear. We focus solely on running and walking gear so that we can be the experts to bring you the best running and walking advice possible.

Through our personalized Fleet Feet fit id® Outfitting process with 3D foot scanning technology, we use data from over 4 million foot scans (and counting) to give us unique insights into how today’s top running insoles fit on a wide variety of feet.

Additionally, thanks to 100,000+ runners participating in our local running clubs and training programs each year, we can see firsthand how Superfeet Insoles perform in the best running shoes for all different types of runners, each with different goals in mind.

Collectively, our experienced team of Fleet Feet editors has tried, tested and fallen in love with a variety of insoles from Superfeet. With this knowledge, we meticulously pour over the smallest details like support, comfort, materials, durability and weight, to decide which insoles and running gear are the best.

From running shoe and gear reviews to workout tips and inspiration, we are your go-to source for running knowledge and motivation.

With this expertise, we’ve tested the best Superfeet Insoles based on:

  • Purpose. Comparing apples to apples
  • Performance. How well does it do its job?
  • Real-world testing. We put them to the test on real runs
  • Price. Is it affordable? Does its performance justify its cost?
  • Sales. Best-selling models are best-sellers for a reason
  • fit idÂŽ data. Our 4 million+ foot scans show how insoles fit for different feet
  • Availability. It won’t be good for you if it’s not in stock
  • Designer interviews. We ask the people who made it

Standing Behind Our Picks

Fleet Feet knows running.

We picked the best Superfeet Insoles for running based on over four decades of experience outfitting runners of all abilities, ages and sizes. If you buy gear from us and you don’t like the way it looks, fits or performs, bring it back within 60 days for a full refund.

Plus, we offer free shipping & returns on all orders over $99 on fleetfeet.com, and we’ll match a lower price from a qualifying retailer. That’s our Happy Fit Guarantee.

fit idÂŽ & Dynamic Pressure Mapping

Buying online isn’t for everyone. To try on your gear before you buy it, visit a local Fleet Feet store for an in-person fitting experience.

We fit you for running shoes and insoles through our proprietary fit id® outfitting process. The one-on-one process uses a state-of-the-art digital scanning system that uses a set of specialized cameras to capture 12 precise data points to construct a 3D profile of your feet. That digital information, combined with Fleet Feet’s dynamic pressure mapping system* helps the store’s highly trained Outfitters assess your natural stride pattern and recommend shoes, socks, and insoles that will provide an optimal fit for the specific length, width, volume and arch height of your feet.

Want to try it for yourself? Find a Fleet Feet location near you.

*Pressure plates are available at select Fleet Feet stores

Free Shipping & Returns

Not sure about buying a new pair of running shoe insoles? Don't sweat it. Get free shipping on orders over $99 when you shop on fleetfeet.com.

If you don't like how your new inserts for running shoes look, fit or feel, we'll take them back within 60 days. That's our Happy Fit Guarantee.

Don't know where to start? Check out our guides for the best running shoes, the best running clothes and the best massage tools to get you going.